Missing important trading feature

When it comes to buying, selling and trading right now you can setup a buy and sell plinth.

I really feel the need for a trading plinth.
For example:
I need clay. I would love to setup a trading plinth where by I give away something rare like gold, in exchange for clay.

Currently I can’t do that. I would need to sell gold for coin. And then buy clay with coin.
Kinda makes it a very cumbersome and unlikely transaction.

Where if I could setup shop and say hey, I need clay, this is my desired trade for gold, it would employ people to work for me in a sense in exchange for a commodity and thus a win win.

Thoughts?

4 Likes

I don’t think this is a really good idea. I think this will make transactions even more unlikely.

Why ? There is a reason why we as humans use “currency” (money) and not trading goods with each other. Money is an abstract concept and it reduces the need that somebody needs to goods you offer and has the goods you need. How likely is it that e.g. I as a trade carry gold and need clay ? (You can find an interesting article on Wiki here)

When money is used to intermediate the exchange of goods and services, it is performing a function as a medium of exchange. It thereby avoids the inefficiencies of a barter system, such as the “coincidence of wants” problem. Money’s most important usage is as a method for comparing the values of dissimilar objects.

It’s more likely that I carry clay or that I need gold separately from each other. We only have very limited amount of storage space in out inventory and I really don’t like to carry around nearly “everything” only that I’m able to trade.

As you can see on public markets there are people selling gold, clay and vice versa and it’s working “fine” most of the times. We all have a base amount of currency because of leveling and we can at least start to trade. If we need more currency we can sell things that are needed and get more coins to buy things.

Just my opinion :slight_smile:

3 Likes

I like it especially for things like gold and clay.
You set up a tradeing stand on a starter world where everyone wants gold.
I have never to this day seen gold on a starter world and would have jumped at the opportunity to trade clay for gold in those early days.

Appreciate the discussion.

I agree that coin is important and should hold its value and be strong in the economy. However I can only speak from in game experience and what I’m suggesting makes a lot of sense for the following reasons…

  • Trading is a leveling profession right now.
    In fact what I have suggested is already in game, it just looks a little bit different.
    You find a player online. Ask them to trade x for x. They win, you win. You also get trading exp by design.
    Only difference is I’m saying let us do the same thing with trading requests for x material while offline same as you would with buy and sell plinths for coins.

As of right now, I have 40,000 coins. I don’t need to sell anything valuable because I dont need the coin quite frankly.
Even if I did sell something of value chances are a new player can’t afford to spend there little amount of coin on that item, and even if they did. No one is selling clay which just so happens to be what I need.

I would happy exchange valuable materials for time spent gathering less valuable materials.

So my coin is useless. I won’t provide any value for the starting player and there will be 0 transactions. That’s just the way it is right now. Doesn’t make any sense.

If I could give something valuable to them so that I may have something that’s easy to obtain yet valuable to me where is the harm in that?

1 Like

Seems to me that I should set up a plinth and start selling clay!

1 Like

In my opinion, this is a problem of balance and not a problem of the trading concept itself. There is currently no need to offer “less valuable materials”. I, for example, have 10 selling and 10 buying plinths. I buy soils and coal and I can pick up at least all few days a few of them. Not in huge amounts in which I would need them but I get at least ~100 all few days (to be fair, it could be more if I would offer better prices).

On the other hand, I only offer valuable items because space is proportional to money because I can’t set up a store as big as I want (not that I currently use all the plinths nor the space available). It’s also very unhandy to supply 100 different items because my base is “relatively far away” from the shops and it would, therefore, require multiple trips to just fill the store.

Yes, there is currently no need for “trading” at all. You can find anything you need fast enought. I set up my shop only because of fun, not because I really need anything. I’m quite sure that a lot of people act the same. And I’m also sure that a lot of people, like me, store huge amounts of ressources and building materials which they don’t really need but also don’t like to “ship” to the market because the profit margin is really low.

From the statement from @KKBell, I assume that he has the clay you need. But I’m also sure his prices will not “fit” your perception (as far as it won’t be a friendship discount). Currently, nearly all prices are either to high or too low (from my subjective feeling). We will find the “real” values of items if there is a real need to trade and if we are not longer able to find or craft everything by us alone (self-supplying).

I’m not saying that your idea at all is bad or that your argument is invalid. I only like to say that there is no “need” for such a feature once the economy and the markets start to work and players are forced to trade. For the moment it would be fine you set up a plinth on the markets and just “wait” - this works fine for me at least.

3 Likes

Pretty much this. There are still a lot of “want & need” loops to come. We also need to start adding our gating systems so players cannot access everything as long as they have the right tool or machine.

Fair point guys.

I do agree that things will be very different once a few more updates go live.

One of the other problems I had was that there is no market on Vena. It’s none existent. Rather than complain, which I am very much trying to be constructive for the games sake, I’ve started looking at other ways to achieve my desired outcome and add value.

I will start a new market on Vena and grow our economy there. I also took a trip to Therka last night and utalised other markets.
Once doing so I saw less of a need for my suggestion while experiencing that was fun.

@KKBell yes do it…! I will come buy your clay. lol.
Where are you located?

Could you please elaborate on this? I don’t understand how allowing people to trade whatever they want for anything else is a “balance” problem. Each player gets to choose if it’s a “balanced” transaction or not, right?

1 Like

I don’t think he was referring to trading not being balanced. Rather that coin is not balanced in terms of supply and demand.

On a side note, I’m glad you messaged here!
I saw a player log in last night and I ran about 5 hours towards them as there name appeared on the horizon they logged out. It was you!! :smiley:

Will you be playing on Vena?!

1 Like

I’m on Berlyn. Haven’t had much time to play though, so I may not get set up for sales any time soon.

Ah that’s okay. I have plenty of ways to manage.