While I like what you guys have going there, there are a few differences between what you’ve got and what I’ve got planned and would like to see. The heavy role play element and the clear end goal of building a library just don’t personally hold appeal.
On that note though, I did say I was going to elaborate further, so I guess I should.
The Set Up:
Basically the idea is simple. As stated earlier there will be different groups (sub-guilds I’ll call them for now) based around the different character classes (I’ll use the typical Mage, Thief and Warrior as place-holders for now) and for those focused solely around Building, Crafting, Selling, and Gathering. Each of these will ideally have a building (or at very least sections/floors of our main guild building) and each sub-guild will have a representative (we can call them other things like the senate, elders, or whatever the guild wants. We can vote on it. It will be fun) who is voted into place and all decisions that would affect the guild as a whole will be voted on amongst these people.
Why separate everything into categories? I want guild members to be able to know where to go, essentially. My thoughts were to have the guild’s main colour be white, and then have a colour to represent each sub-guild (like yellow for thieves, red for warriors, green for crafters, etc.) This way if you need a warrior for you party, you can head to the red building. Need to find someone to craft a bow out of the materials you’ve created? Head to headquarters and flag down someone wearing green. It would keep things like this organized, streamlined, and simple. Hopefully this would let members pursue the areas of the game that interest them the most while having a network of others who, while pursuing different aims, can come together and help each other out.
My thoughts were that the representatives of each sub-guild would be voted into place by guild members (who themselves are sorted into each group – character class by default, and then can sign up to be one of merchant, builder, etc.) That way, if a guild leader is inactive for a long time or people dislike them a vote can be held and someone new can replace them.
Another key point to my idea was having guild members be able to register mining spots with the guild or sign up with the guild for raids or whatever else like this. After which the guild would provide help with equipment and whatnot but then take some of the spoils of what you gain. This way the guild bank and guild armouries and the rest will grow while members have an easy way of accessing the wealth within.
That’s about all I can type up at the moment but I would love to get more people to collaborate with and help me build upon and refine this guild.