Random Thoughts

I think we’re spending too much time debating the economy and other problems without addressing why Boundless is in the state it’s in to begin with. The economy didn’t drive away the majority of the player base. Years of stagnant development, limited content, repetitive gameplay, excessive grinding, and a lack of meaningful progression contributed to that. The economy has deteriorated as the population declined because it was designed around a thriving community of players buying, selling, crafting, and trading with one another. When those players disappear, the entire system begins to break down.

We can debate coin sinks, wealth inequality, market manipulation, or even wiping the economy, but none of those things address the fundamental problem. If we fixed the economy tomorrow, how many former players would actually return? I’d argue virtually none, because nothing about the gameplay that caused them to leave would have changed. They would return to the same limited content, the same progression systems, and the same lack of meaningful development. Fixing the economy might improve things for the small number of people still playing, but it isn’t going to revive the game.

There’s also a much bigger issue that rarely gets enough attention: the lack of trust and confidence in Monumental. After years of little meaningful development and limited communication about the game’s future, what reason do players have to believe things will improve? More importantly, what assurance do they have that Boundless will even remain online? When a game depends on servers controlled by a company, and there’s no clear long-term commitment to maintaining them, the possibility of those servers eventually shutting down becomes a legitimate concern. That doesn’t mean a shutdown has been announced or is imminent, but the uncertainty alone is damaging.

Think about what we’re asking of new or returning players. Invest hundreds or potentially thousands of hours gathering resources, building elaborate structures, establishing shops, and creating entire communities in a game whose future remains uncertain. Why would someone make that investment when they have little confidence their creations will still exist years from now? This is especially problematic for Boundless because so much of its appeal revolves around permanent, persistent worlds and the time players invest in them. Without trust in the game’s longevity, even its strongest features become difficult to sell.

And that’s where Monumental comes into the picture. Ultimately, the future of Boundless rests with them, not the remaining players trying to keep its economy functioning. The community cannot develop new content, overhaul progression, expand combat, introduce meaningful gameplay systems, or provide the long-term direction needed to attract and retain players. More importantly, the community cannot restore confidence in the game’s future on Monumental’s behalf. That requires transparency, consistent communication, a credible development roadmap, and actual progress that players can see.

What’s particularly frustrating is that Boundless has a genuinely unique foundation. Its building system, chiseling, connected worlds, and player-driven communities offer something that very few games replicate. The potential is there, and the fact that people are still having these discussions shows that some players still care deeply about it. But potential alone doesn’t sustain an MMO. Players need reasons to start playing, reasons to keep playing, and reasons to come back after they’ve left. They also need confidence that the time and effort they invest won’t disappear because the servers are eventually switched off.

At this point, I think we need to distinguish between maintaining Boundless for the handful of players who remain and actually giving the game a future. Those are two very different things. We can continue discussing economic adjustments, but without meaningful development and restored trust in Monumental, we’re ultimately just trying to make a declining game more comfortable for the people who haven’t left yet.

The community can keep Boundless alive for a while, but only Monumental can restore the confidence, development, and long-term commitment needed to give it a future.

6 Likes

I would simplify it to:

Unless we debate things we control or influence, we are wasting our energy.
While the game is waiting to be played.

4 Likes

I would mostly agree, but had I just typed that it would have zero context. Expecting to have any impact on the game to increase player counts or make the game better is dependent on Monumental.

3 Likes

I think there is something important we should consider: we are constantly discussing what Boundless has lost, what Monumental hasn’t done, and what would need to change for the game to become successful again.

But perhaps we are spending so much time looking backwards that we are forgetting what is still possible.

Boundless is far from a perfect game, but it still offers an experience that is difficult to find elsewhere. Its world, building freedom, player-driven economy and interconnected planets give it a unique identity, as you said.

I don’t think we should underestimate the value of what still exists.

Not every discussion has to end with a demand for new content or a debate about whether Monumental has failed. Sometimes we should also be asking ourselves how we can make the most of the game we currently have.

A community doesn’t necessarily have to wait for developers to give it a reason to be active. Players can create their own reasons to stay, collaborate and make the world feel alive again.

I’m not saying this replaces development or that Monumental has no responsibilities. The lack of development and communication remains a real problem. But if we genuinely care about Boundless, perhaps we should stop treating its future as something that can only be decided by what happens next at Monumental.

I’d also encourage everyone to ask themselves this question: even if Monumental released a new update and started communicating with the community again, would former players actually be willing to return? And more importantly, how many of them would be willing to get involved again in the long term?

We talk a lot about what Monumental should do to bring the game back to life, but we should also ask ourselves what we, as a community, can still contribute to Boundless.

The question isn’t just whether Boundless can become what it once was.

It’s also whether we are willing to give it a future with what we have today.

If we constantly discourage the few active players who are still around simply because Monumental hasn’t announced any plans or made a decision about the future yet, we’re only accelerating Boundless’s death. Instead, some have put so much effort into trying to destroy Boundless, rather than seeking to highlight its true potential.

In Minecraft, defeating the Ender Dragon can be done in 5 hours. Expect around 500 hours to complete pretty much everything, and that’s without even mentioning its repetitive gameplay.

Question: Have people stopped playing or uninstalled Minecraft because of that?

4 Likes

Evidently random thoughts are not allowed in the thread random thoughts. Thought (flag) police strike again.

Anyway,

But what can we do? People have tried to post stuff on social media. Given keys away. Combatted negative reviews on Steam. I think the only thing that will bring new players in inve$tment

I agree that investment is probably necessary to attract new players, but investment alone isn’t enough. We also need to consider what happens after those players arrive.

Better onboarding, more visibility, community events and regular communication could all help. Not everything requires a major update or a huge budget.

But we also need to stop pushing the idea that Boundless is already dead. If even the remaining community keeps discouraging people from playing or supporting the game, why would anyone new give it a chance?

We can’t control Monumental’s investment decisions, but we can still influence the atmosphere around the game.

I’m tired of debating this. But I will answer your questions:

Some would, but I think it also depends on the update. Look when it was announced that Monumental bought the game, so many old players posted. I also think an update alone won’t do much you’d need a development plan and marketing.

Focusing on getting old players back is the wrong approach, the focus should be on getting new players as the game never had a lot of players to begin with. I’ve stated it numerous times that adding something new which might add 5% more to the game, still keeps the 95% of the base game and old players would get bored quick.

Yes, people have stopped or uninstalled, but its a bad comparison. Minecraft will live on if Mojang or Microsoft shut down. Minecraft gets updates, it has a huge community, constantly getting mods, player run servers and tons of other things.

We don’t have to post anything negative, it’s already out there all over the internet. I also wouldn’t suggest Boundless to anyone at least at its current price and the way Monumental is and this is coming from myself who loves the game.

I also think you miss my point, without Monumental we are stuck where we are with an average of 15 players. If players are ok with that I understand where they are coming from, but for myself it just makes me not want to even invest my time in it and judging by the player counts many others agree.

1 Like

My Minecraft example might not have been the best one, fair enough. But I still think there’s an interesting point worth making.

If a game relies heavily on mods to fix fundamental problems or significantly change its original gameplay, doesn’t that raise questions about the developers’ decisions and how well they’ve listened to their community? Of course, mods can also extend a game’s lifespan and offer additional freedom, so I’m not saying modding is inherently a bad thing.

As for Minecraft, I don’t recall Bedrock Edition, including its mobile version, having the same modding freedom as Java Edition. Bedrock does support add-ons, but its possibilities are much more limited compared to Java. In that sense, Java remains the more flexible experience for players who enjoy modifying their games.

Now, regarding Minecraft-style servers, I remember Boundless players asking for something similar long before Sovereign Worlds were introduced. And eventually, we got them.

But then came the controversy about Sovereign Worlds supposedly dividing the community.

Who asked for them in the first place? The community did.

I think there’s an important contradiction here. Players asked for more freedom and control over their own environments, Wonderstruck eventually provided that option, and then some people complained that it was dividing the player base.

There was also another practical benefit. Boundless had plenty of disputes over land ownership, neighbouring builds, roads crossing people’s intended building areas, and players reserving plots around other people’s projects. These disagreements were a recurring source of frustration.

Sovereign Worlds gave owners more control over permissions and who could build on their planets. It also shifted some of the responsibility for managing local disputes towards the world owners, rather than leaving every disagreement to be dealt with centrally.

I’m not saying Sovereign Worlds were a perfect solution or that everyone wanted them. But I think we should acknowledge that developers sometimes implement features because the community itself asks for them, and those same features can later become controversial.

Now, regarding the argument that people everywhere on the internet consider Boundless a dead game, I don’t think we should simply accept that as an unavoidable reality.

I understand why people have that perception. The lack of updates, the declining player population and the lack of communication from Monumental have all contributed to it. I’m not denying any of that.

But I think there’s a difference between a game having a small player base and a game being dead.

You’ve actually made that distinction yourself in previous discussions. Back in 2025, you described Boundless as an active game with a small community rather than a dead game.

And that’s exactly my point. If we keep repeating everywhere that Boundless is dead, we contribute to reinforcing that perception. Someone discovering the game today, reading Steam reviews or browsing the forums, might simply decide not to give it a chance.

We cannot control what Monumental does, and we certainly cannot manufacture new content ourselves. But we can choose how we talk about the game and whether we encourage people to discover what is still there.

I’m not suggesting we should hide its problems or pretend everything is fine. I just don’t see why we should actively contribute to discouraging the few potential new players who might still be interested.

At some point, we also need to acknowledge that the community doesn’t always agree on what it wants. And perhaps we should stop making things even harder for a game that many of us still want to see survive.

I’d also like to take this opportunity to thank you for these exchanges. I think our discussions show that we can have different opinions, disagree on certain things and still have constructive and respectful conversations with each other. That’s something I genuinely appreciate, and I think it’s something our community could use more of.