Titanium makes awesome sporks. (We have about half a dozen of them, mostly with Starfleet logos on them. You just can't give me money.)
It just isn't good for everything, though.
One notes in passing that in D&D they resorted to "mithral" because no familiar metal really had the characteristics they wanted for armor and blades; Marvel Comics came up with "vibranium" and "adamantium," Star Trek has "duranium." The game would probably be better off making up a name for an Oortian metal or alloy than going with materials (at least) some of us know wouldn't be ideal.
"Oortium" is too obvious; "Boundlessite" is too corny (or cheesy, depending on whether you prefer cheese over corn), but "vitallium" and "endurium" (or "endurite") are certainly viable names (IMHO, and I'm not suggesting they be the choices--just indicating a method of approach.